Best Thanksgiving Roasting Pans Compared
AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

Choosing a Thanksgiving roasting pan means weighing the cooking jobs you want it to handle against the cleanup you are willing to do. Stainless steel and nonstick pans can both roast a turkey, but they behave differently when you brown vegetables, make gravy from drippings, or scrub away baked-on fat. Stainless steel is the stronger all-purpose pick for cooks who want lasting performance and useful pan drippings; nonstick suits households that put easy release and a quicker wash first. Before buying either, check the pan’s interior dimensions and stated capacity against your bird, oven, and storage space.

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get your next haul delivered free with Prime

  • Fast, free delivery on millions of items
  • Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
  • Member-only deals all year
Start your free Prime trial Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
3
compared
3
brands
3
materials
3.5 inches stated
max pan depth
Which thanksgiving roasting pan should you buy?
★ Top Pick
EWFEN 17 × 13-Inch Stainless S
Best Overall for Thanksgiving Flexibility
Includes V-shaped and flat racks for different roasting setups.
See on Amazon →
Hosts roasting a large turkey who prefer a coated surface and want a rack that lifts the bird above the drippings.
17 × 13-Inch Nonstick Turkey R
Description states capacity for a turkey up to 22 pounds.
View on Amazon →
Smaller households or cooks who often roast chicken, modest cuts of meat, or vegetables and want dishwasher-safe care.
Glad Nonstick 15 × 10.3-Inch R
Smaller footprint than the two 17-inch alternatives.
View on Amazon →
Pan depth — compared
EWFEN 17 × 13-Inch Stainless S3.5 inches stated
Glad Nonstick 15 × 10.3-Inch R2.8 inches
Pros & cons at a glance
EWFEN 17 × 13-Inch Stainless S
✓ Includes V-shaped and flat racks for different roasting setups.
✗ Large footprint may be awkward in compact ovens and sinks.
17 × 13-Inch Nonstick Turkey R
✓ Description states capacity for a turkey up to 22 pounds.
✗ Listed dimensions conflict with the 17 × 13-inch product title.
Glad Nonstick 15 × 10.3-Inch R
✓ Smaller footprint than the two 17-inch alternatives.
✗ Smaller and shallower than the other pans, limiting room for a large bird and drippings.
BEST OVERALL FOR THANKSGIVING FLEXIBILITY
EWFEN 17 × 13-Inch Stainless Steel Turkey Roaster with V-Shaped and Flat Racks

EWFEN 17 × 13-Inch Stainless Steel Turkey Roaster with V-Shaped and Flat Racks

  • ✔ Pan dimensions: 17 × 12.6 inches listed; product title states 17 × 13 inches
  • ✔ Pan depth: 3.5 inches stated
  • ✔ Material: Stainless steel
BEST FOR A LARGE TURKEY
17 × 13-Inch Nonstick Turkey Roasting Pan with U-Shaped Rack

17 × 13-Inch Nonstick Turkey Roasting Pan with U-Shaped Rack

  • ✔ Pan dimensions: Title: 17 × 13 inches; listed measurements: 15 × 8 × 3 inches
  • ✔ Stated turkey capacity: Up to 22 pounds
  • ✔ Material: Aluminized steel in description; carbon steel in materials listing
BEST COMPACT PICK FOR SMALLER ROASTS
Glad Nonstick 15 × 10.3-Inch Roasting Pan with V-Shaped Rack

Glad Nonstick 15 × 10.3-Inch Roasting Pan with V-Shaped Rack

  • ✔ Pan dimensions: 15 × 10.3 inches, excluding handles
  • ✔ Pan depth: 2.8 inches
  • ✔ Material: Heavy-duty carbon steel

At a Glance

CriteriaStainless steel roasting panNonstick roasting panWinner
Turkey capacity and fitOften available in sturdy sizes for large birds; confirm interior measurements and rack fit.Available in turkey-sized models, but coating and construction vary; verify dimensions and oven rating.Depends
Browning and pan drippingsUncoated surface supports browning and lets drippings collect for gravy.Can brown food, though the surface and drippings may not behave like uncoated steel.A
Food releaseFood can stick, especially if the pan is dry or overheated.Coating helps food and residue release with less effort.B
CleanupBaked-on residue may need soaking and scrubbing.Usually easier to wash by hand; avoid abrasive pads and harsh utensils.B
Durability and careNo coating to wear away; resists routine utensil contact, though steel can discolor or warp if poorly made or overheated.Coating can scratch or degrade over time, especially with high heat or rough handling.A
VersatilityWorks well for roasting, deglazing, and stovetop gravy when the manufacturer rates it for burner use.Useful for roasting; stovetop use depends on the model and may be restricted by coating or construction.A
Value over timeHigher upfront cost may pay off through long service life and broader cooking use.Can be a good buy for easier cleanup, but replacement may be needed if the coating wears.Depends

EWFEN 17 × 13-Inch Stainless Steel Turkey Roaster with V-Shaped and Flat Racks

EWFEN 17 × 13-Inch Stainless Steel Turkey Roaster with V-Shaped and Flat Racks
OUR VERDICT
Best Overall for Thanksgiving Flexibility
VIEW ON AMAZON

For a holiday meal with more than one job for the roasting pan, EWFEN’s two-rack setup gives it the clearest edge. The 17 × 13-inch stainless steel pan comes with a V-shaped rack for poultry and a flat rack for other roasting or baking arrangements. That flexibility makes it a stronger all-around choice than the single U-shaped rack on the larger nonstick pan, particularly if we want one piece of cookware to cover turkey and other dishes across the season.The stated 3.5-inch depth helps contain juices and sauces, useful when the meal includes a substantial roast or a layered dish. Stainless steel also avoids a nonstick coating, which may appeal to cooks who want a surface they can handle without coating-specific utensil restrictions. The tradeoff is that stainless steel food release and cleanup may require more attention than either coated alternative; the product description’s easy-clean claims don’t eliminate the possibility of stuck-on residue. The set is also the largest listed at 17 × 12.6 inches, so we should measure oven and sink clearance before committing.Compared with the capacity-led nonstick pan, EWFEN offers more rack choices and a deeper stated profile, while the other model describes a 22-pound turkey capacity and a coating designed for easy release. Glad is easier to fit in tighter kitchens but offers less roasting area and only one rack. We rank EWFEN first for versatility, with the caveat that its size and stainless steel upkeep suit a cook prepared to manage both.

Pros:

  • Includes V-shaped and flat racks for different roasting setups.
  • Stainless steel construction has no nonstick coating.
  • 17 × 13-inch pan with a stated 3.5-inch depth for containing juices.
  • Removable rack can lift poultry above drippings.

Cons:

  • Large footprint may be awkward in compact ovens and sinks.
  • Stainless steel may take more scrubbing than the coated alternatives.
  • No maximum oven temperature is provided in the supplied details.

Best for: Hosts who want one large pan with two rack arrangements for turkey, other roasts, and holiday sides.

Not ideal for: Cooks with limited oven or sink clearance, or anyone prioritizing a nonstick surface and the simplest release.

Pan dimensions:
17 × 12.6 inches listed; product title states 17 × 13 inches
Pan depth:
3.5 inches stated
Material:
Stainless steel
Finish:
Polished
Included racks:
V-shaped rack and flat rack
Handle material:
Stainless steel

Bottom line: Choose EWFEN for the most versatile Thanksgiving setup if your oven can accommodate its large stainless steel pan.

Our verdict
“Choose EWFEN for the most versatile Thanksgiving setup if your oven can accommodate its large stainless steel pan.”

17 × 13-Inch Nonstick Turkey Roasting Pan with U-Shaped Rack

17 × 13-Inch Nonstick Turkey Roasting Pan with U-Shaped Rack
OUR VERDICT
Best for a Large Turkey
VIEW ON AMAZON

When the centerpiece is a large bird, this pan puts capacity first: its description says it can accommodate a turkey up to 22 pounds, and the angled external handles are intended to preserve roasting area. That makes it the more direct turkey-specific choice than Glad’s smaller 15 × 10.3-inch pan. The U-shaped rack lifts the meat away from the bottom, leaving space for heat circulation and for drippings to collect beneath.The nonstick finish is a practical advantage when we want browned food to release more readily and cleanup to be less demanding after dinner. It is described as free of PTFE and PFOA, as well as cadmium and lead. Its stated oven limit is 450°F, which is lower than Glad’s listed 464°F; for ordinary turkey roasting that difference may not decide the purchase, but it makes Glad the better match when a recipe calls for temperatures above 450°F. Coated cookware also calls for care with utensils and cleaning, and the product details do not specify dishwasher safety.Compared with EWFEN, this pan gives up the second rack and stainless steel construction in favor of a stated turkey capacity and a release-friendly surface. Its title calls the pan 17 × 13 inches, but the supplied dimensions also list 15 × 8 × 3 inches, so buyers should verify the actual pan measurements before buying. We place it second because its large-turkey focus is compelling, but the conflicting size details make fit confirmation especially important.

Pros:

  • Description states capacity for a turkey up to 22 pounds.
  • U-shaped rack raises meat above collected juices and grease.
  • Nonstick coating is described as free of PTFE, PFOA, cadmium, and lead.
  • Angled external handles are designed to leave more room inside the pan.

Cons:

  • Listed dimensions conflict with the 17 × 13-inch product title.
  • 450°F stated maximum is below Glad’s listed 464°F limit.
  • Only one rack is included, and dishwasher safety is not specified.

Best for: Hosts roasting a large turkey who prefer a coated surface and want a rack that lifts the bird above the drippings.

Not ideal for: Buyers who want stainless steel, multiple rack options, dishwasher guidance, or unambiguous listed dimensions.

Pan dimensions:
Title: 17 × 13 inches; listed measurements: 15 × 8 × 3 inches
Stated turkey capacity:
Up to 22 pounds
Material:
Aluminized steel in description; carbon steel in materials listing
Finish:
Nonstick
Rack:
U-shaped rack with lifting handles
Maximum oven temperature:
450°F

Bottom line: Pick this model for its stated large-turkey capacity and nonstick release, after confirming the pan’s actual dimensions.

Our verdict
“Pick this model for its stated large-turkey capacity and nonstick release, after confirming the pan’s actual dimensions.”

Glad Nonstick 15 × 10.3-Inch Roasting Pan with V-Shaped Rack

Glad Nonstick 15 × 10.3-Inch Roasting Pan with V-Shaped Rack
OUR VERDICT
Best Compact Pick for Smaller Roasts
VIEW ON AMAZON

Glad is the easiest fit of the group when a full-size turkey pan would dominate the oven or cabinet. Its 15 × 10.3-inch footprint is better suited to chicken, a smaller roast, or vegetables than to the largest Thanksgiving bird. The V-shaped rack still provides a raised platform for airflow, and the stated 2.8-inch depth gives this option a familiar roasting-pan shape without the bulk of EWFEN’s deeper, wider model.Cleanup is its strongest practical distinction: the pan is described as dishwasher safe, and its nonstick coating is listed as PFOA- and PTFE-free. Glad also specifies a 464°F oven limit, the highest of the three listed limits. However, it is explicitly not broiler safe, cannot be used on a stovetop or open flame, and the care instructions caution against metal tools and abrasive cleaners. Those restrictions make it less flexible for turning pan drippings directly into gravy than an uncoated pan designed for stovetop use.Compared with the 17-inch options, Glad is easier to store and makes more sense for a smaller holiday gathering, but it gives up roasting area and capacity information. EWFEN offers a deeper pan and two rack styles; the large nonstick model explicitly claims room for a 22-pound turkey. We rank Glad third for Thanksgiving because compact size and dishwasher care are useful advantages, yet buyers planning a substantial turkey dinner may quickly outgrow it.

Pros:

  • Smaller footprint than the two 17-inch alternatives.
  • Dishwasher-safe care is specified.
  • V-shaped rack raises food for airflow.
  • Listed 464°F maximum oven temperature is highest in this comparison.

Cons:

  • Smaller and shallower than the other pans, limiting room for a large bird and drippings.
  • Not broiler safe and not for stovetop or open-flame use.
  • Nonstick care instructions rule out abrasive cleaners and metal cutting tools.

Best for: Smaller households or cooks who often roast chicken, modest cuts of meat, or vegetables and want dishwasher-safe care.

Not ideal for: Hosts roasting a large turkey, cooks who need broiler or stovetop use, or anyone wanting a pan for making gravy over a burner.

Pan dimensions:
15 × 10.3 inches, excluding handles
Pan depth:
2.8 inches
Material:
Heavy-duty carbon steel
Finish:
Nonstick; PFOA- and PTFE-free
Rack:
V-shaped iron rack
Maximum oven temperature:
464°F

Bottom line: Choose Glad for smaller roasts and straightforward cleanup, but look to a 17-inch pan for a large Thanksgiving turkey.

Our verdict
“Choose Glad for smaller roasts and straightforward cleanup, but look to a 17-inch pan for a large Thanksgiving turkey.”

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Key Differences

The central tradeoff is control during cooking versus convenience afterward. Stainless steel offers a dependable surface for browning and collecting fond, the browned bits that can add flavor to gravy. That advantage matters most when you plan to use the roasting pan for more than holding the turkey. A nonstick surface releases food more readily, which can simplify serving and washing, but its coating calls for gentler utensils and care. Pan design, thickness, handles, rack, and manufacturer instructions still matter: material alone does not guarantee even heating or a good fit.

Capacity is a practical issue for both options, not an automatic win for either. A pan’s advertised turkey size may not account for the bird’s shape, the rack, or clearance from oven walls and heating elements. Measure the interior cooking area and check the pan’s total dimensions against your oven. If you regularly roast a large turkey, choose a sturdy pan with handles you can grip safely while wearing oven mitts. If you have a smaller oven or limited cabinet space, a more compact pan that fits your actual meals may be a better purchase than the largest model.

For most cooks who want one Thanksgiving pan to keep for years and use for gravy, stainless steel is the better default. Nonstick earns its place when easier cleanup is a high priority and you are willing to follow the care limits and replace the pan if its coating deteriorates. Pay more for stainless steel when its construction, handles, rack, and fit meet your needs; a premium price by itself does not make a pan better. Choose nonstick when the time saved after dinner matters more than stovetop flexibility or a surface built for long service.

Detailed Comparison

Turkey capacity and fit (major difference)

Neither material wins on capacity by itself: both are sold in sizes intended for holiday birds, and actual usable space varies by model. The difference is minor until the pan does not fit the turkey or oven, at which point it becomes the deciding factor. Measure the interior and exterior dimensions, allow room for the rack and handles, and check your oven’s usable space before choosing.

Browning and pan drippings (Stainless steel roasting pan wins — moderate)

Stainless steel wins by a moderate margin for cooks who want deeply browned vegetables or drippings for gravy. Its uncoated surface is suited to collecting browned bits that can be loosened with liquid, provided the pan is approved for stovetop use. Nonstick can roast successfully, but its coating and care limits make it less suited to vigorous searing or high-heat stovetop steps. For a cook who serves gravy from the pan, this difference is meaningful; for someone using prepared gravy, it matters less.

Food release (Nonstick roasting pan wins — moderate)

Nonstick wins clearly for releasing sticky food and making it easier to lift roasted vegetables or remove residue. The gap is moderate in everyday roasting and can feel major for cooks who dislike scrubbing after a long meal. Stainless steel can still work well with proper preparation, but food is more likely to adhere, especially when the pan is dry or the cooking conditions are unsuitable.

Cleanup (Nonstick roasting pan wins — moderate)

Nonstick usually takes less effort to wash, so it wins this criterion by a moderate margin. A gentle hand wash is often enough, although the coating should not be attacked with abrasive cleaners or metal tools. Stainless steel may need soaking and scrubbing after sticky drippings bake on. If the pan will be used only once or twice a year, cleanup convenience may be worth more to you than the difference in long-term versatility.

Durability and care (Stainless steel roasting pan wins — major)

Stainless steel wins by a major margin for long-term resilience because it has no coating that can scratch, peel, or lose its release properties. It still deserves reasonable care, and thin or poorly made pans may warp. Nonstick requires more careful handling and heat management, and its useful life depends on keeping the coating intact. A household that cooks often or wants to pass cookware down has a strong reason to favor stainless steel.

Versatility (Stainless steel roasting pan wins — moderate)

Stainless steel wins by a moderate margin because it is typically better suited to browning, roasting, and making gravy in the same pan, subject to the maker’s stovetop guidance. Nonstick is effective for roasting and easy release, but some models are not designed for burner use, and its coating narrows the range of tools and heat levels you should use. Confirm instructions before moving either pan from oven to stovetop.

Value over time (moderate difference)

The value winner depends on how long you keep the pan and which convenience matters most. Stainless steel can justify a higher purchase price through durability and broader use, making it the stronger long-term value for frequent cooks. Nonstick can be the better immediate value for occasional holiday roasting if easy release and cleanup are top priorities. Avoid paying a premium for features you will not use, and compare construction and dimensions alongside price.

Stainless steel roasting pan: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Supports browning and flavorful pan drippings for gravy.
  • No coating to scratch or wear away.
  • Usually offers more freedom for roasting and, when approved, stovetop finishing.
  • Can provide better long-term value for frequent use.

Cons:

  • Food may stick without suitable preparation.
  • Baked-on drippings can take more effort to clean.
  • Some models are heavy, and quality varies by thickness and construction.
  • Stovetop compatibility should be confirmed before making gravy in the pan.

Nonstick roasting pan: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Food and residue tend to release more easily.
  • Cleanup is often quicker after a large holiday meal.
  • A practical choice for cooks who prefer less scrubbing.
  • Turkey-sized options are available, with dimensions varying by model.

Cons:

  • The coating needs gentle utensils and careful cleaning.
  • Coating may scratch or degrade, limiting useful life.
  • Less suited to high-heat browning and pan-sauce work.
  • Stovetop use may be limited or disallowed by the manufacturer.

Who Should Choose What

Choose Stainless steel roasting pan if:

  • You make gravy from turkey drippings in the roasting pan.
  • You want a pan that can handle repeated holiday and everyday use.
  • Browning and long-term durability matter more to you than the fastest cleanup.
  • You want the option to finish cooking on the stovetop and the model is rated for it.

Choose Nonstick roasting pan if:

  • You value easy food release and a quicker wash after dinner.
  • You roast occasionally and are comfortable using gentle tools and care practices.
  • You rarely make gravy from the pan drippings.
  • You prefer a convenient surface and accept that the coating may need eventual replacement.

Skip both if: Skip both until you find a pan whose interior dimensions, handles, and oven rating fit your turkey and oven. A pan that is too large, too small, or awkward to lift will frustrate you regardless of its surface.

Value for Money

Pay more for stainless steel when you will use the pan regularly, make gravy in it, or want a durable piece of cookware that can serve several jobs. Its value comes from longevity and cooking flexibility, not from the material name alone. A well-made pan with sound construction and secure handles is a better buy than an expensive but thin model. Nonstick can be worth its price for occasional roasting when reduced scrubbing is your main priority. Treat the coating as a wear item: if it is damaged, follow the manufacturer’s guidance rather than continuing to use it.

Final Verdict

For most Thanksgiving cooks buying one roasting pan, choose stainless steel. It gives you the stronger foundation for browning, gravy, repeated use, and a longer service life. Choose nonstick if food release and cleanup matter more than those advantages, particularly if you roast only occasionally and will care for the coating gently. The biggest deciding factor is whether you want the pan to help make the meal’s gravy and handle future cooking jobs, or mainly to make this year’s roast easier to wash. Either way, confirm the pan fits your bird and oven before buying.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which roasting pan is better for Thanksgiving turkey, stainless steel or nonstick?

Both can roast a turkey if the pan is large enough and rated for the cooking temperature. Stainless steel is the better all-purpose option when you want browned drippings for gravy and a pan to use for years. Nonstick is a good fit when easier release and cleanup matter most.

Can I make gravy in a nonstick roasting pan?

Some models allow stovetop use, but others do not. Check the manufacturer’s instructions before placing the pan over a burner. If stovetop gravy is a priority, stainless steel usually offers the more flexible choice.

What size roasting pan do I need for Thanksgiving?

Use the pan’s interior dimensions and the turkey’s size and shape as your guide. Check that the bird fits with room for the rack and that the pan, handles, and oven clearance all work together. Advertised turkey capacity is only a starting point.

Is a more expensive roasting pan worth it?

It can be worth paying more for sturdy construction, comfortable handles, a useful rack, and a size that fits your oven. Stainless steel may offer better long-term value for frequent use; nonstick may be worth it when easy cleanup is your main benefit. Price alone does not guarantee better performance.

You May Also Like

How To Stock Up On Frank’s RedHot Buffalo Wings Hot Sauce: 6-Pack For $17.40 With S&S

A Slickdeals listing reports six 23-ounce bottles of Frank’s RedHot Buffalo Wings sauce for $17.40 with Subscribe & Save at Amazon; terms may vary.

Why Serious Home Cooks Care About Cookware Materials

Because the right cookware materials can transform your cooking results, serious home cooks pay close attention to these choices to ensure safety and excellence.

The Kitchen Upgrades That Actually Save Time Every Day

Cook smarter with these time-saving kitchen upgrades that will revolutionize your daily routine—discover how to make your kitchen more efficient today.

Twenty Below Coffee Co. closing July 5

Twenty Below Coffee Co. in Fargo will cease operations on July 5, ending its presence after years in the community. The closure impacts local coffee lovers and employees.