TL;DR
Get your next haul delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Which? says its member research found that 49% of respondents prefer gifts they have specifically asked for, while 50% value making memories with family and friends over physical presents. The consumer group also found that unwanted gifts may go unused or be passed on, and recommends choosing presents around recipients’ preferences, interests and budgets.
Which? has published Christmas gift advice based on member research, finding that 49% of respondents prefer a present they have specifically requested and 50% value shared experiences with friends and family over a physical item. The consumer group says unwanted gifts can end up stored away or passed on, making recipients’ tastes a more useful guide than surprise or price alone.
In Which?’s survey, a quarter of respondents said they would put an unwanted gift in a cupboard or drawer, while 44% said they would pass one on, for example by donating it to a charity shop or giving it to a raffle or tombola. The figures suggest that some presents are not used by the people who receive them. Which? does not provide the survey’s sample size or fieldwork dates in the supplied report, so the findings should be read as its member survey rather than a measure of all UK shoppers.
The group’s main recommendation is to ask what someone wants, or pay attention to things they have mentioned wanting but would not buy for themselves. Members’ examples included Welsh whisky, a pie maker that its recipient used regularly, and a preferred brand of body wash bought by friends who knew the recipient’s taste. These accounts illustrate the advice; they are individual examples, not evidence that a particular type of gift will suit everyone.
Experiences and time together were another recurring theme. Half of respondents said they valued making memories with family and friends more than receiving a physical item. Members described presents such as a vintage-car hire day, a weekend spent with relatives and tickets to a live show paired with a meal. Which? also points to interests such as gardening, reading, model-making and sport as potential starting points for choosing a more personal gift.
How Recipient Preferences Shape Gift Choices
The findings matter to shoppers trying to spend thoughtfully during the Christmas season. Which?’s numbers point to a practical risk: a gift that misses the recipient’s tastes may be stored away or passed on, rather than used. Asking directly, or checking what someone enjoys, can help reduce guesswork; it does not guarantee that a present will be well received.
The report also offers a reminder that price is not the same as thoughtfulness. Members most commonly considered £20–£49 appropriate for family gifts, while comments about presents for friends stressed the personal meaning rather than the amount spent. A modest gift tailored to someone’s habits may be a better fit than a more expensive generic item, though budgets and preferences vary.
For people who do not want another object, an outing or shared activity may be suitable. Experiences can also be shaped around what the recipient enjoys, from a meal to a concert. The survey reflects member opinions and examples, not a universal rule that experiences are always preferable.
Popular right now
De'Longhi Dinamica Plus Fully Automatic Espresso Machine
Vitamix 5200 Professional-Grade Blender, 64 oz. Container, Black
TCL 65 Inch QM8L Series SQD-Mini LED QLED 4K Smart Google TV
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
What Which? Members Said They Value
Which? presents the advice as a response to members’ accounts of gifts they loved and presents that went unwanted or unused. Alongside its survey percentages, the report includes personal examples to show what recipients considered thoughtful: gifts connected to hobbies, practical items they would not have selected themselves, and activities spent with family or friends.
Members cited a smart telescope that helped someone continue a stargazing hobby, an angling experience, and a set of shortlisted novels for a keen reader. The report contrasts such tailored choices with generic presents, including bath sets, which some members saw as showing little thought. These comments are illustrative and do not establish that a given category is broadly unpopular.
The source also notes that Which? may receive affiliate commission when readers click retailer links and make purchases, saying this supports its work as a consumer organisation. The supplied material does not provide a survey methodology, sample size or date, and does not give detailed findings for every gifting mistake mentioned in the article title.
““I never would have thought of it, but I’ve used it regularly ever since.””
— Which? member
Limits of the Member Survey
The supplied Which? report does not state how many members took part, when the survey was conducted, or how respondents were recruited. It is not possible from the published details provided here to assess how representative the figures are of consumers generally. The percentages describe Which? members’ answers, not all gift recipients.
The report also does not quantify how often gifts are unused, or compare outcomes by price, recipient age or type of present. Its examples and recommendations reflect members’ experiences and preferences; they cannot predict whether a particular person will like a specific gift.
Using the Advice Before Christmas
Which?’s immediate advice is to check what the recipient wants, consider activities they would enjoy together, and choose something connected to their hobbies or everyday needs. Shoppers can also use the group’s gift guides for ideas, but should match any suggestion to the person rather than treat a category as a guaranteed choice.
The source does not announce a follow-up survey or a forthcoming change to the advice. The next step for shoppers is to use the recommendations while choosing presents; further detail about the research would be needed to judge how broadly its findings apply.
Key Questions
What did Which? find about the gifts people prefer?
Which? says 49% of surveyed members prefer gifts they have specifically asked for. The report also says 50% value making memories with friends and family more than receiving a physical present.
What happens to unwanted gifts, according to the survey?
A quarter of respondents said they would put an unwanted gift away in a cupboard or drawer, and 44% said they would pass it on, including by donating it to charity or giving it to a raffle or tombola.
How much do Which? members think is appropriate to spend on family gifts?
The report says the majority of members surveyed considered £20–£49 appropriate for family gifts. It does not say that this range suits every household or budget.
Does Which? recommend buying only experiences?
No. Experiences were a popular theme, but the report also describes valued practical and hobby-related gifts. Its advice is to consider the individual recipient’s preferences rather than follow one gift type.
How representative are the survey results?
The supplied report does not give the survey’s sample size, fieldwork dates or recruitment method. Its percentages should be understood as responses from Which? members, not as figures for the whole UK population.
Source: which.co.uk
